Advice

By Simon Fairhurst

DIY brand workshop or hire an agency? An honest guide

I make a workshop template, so you might expect me to say “do it yourself”. The honest answer is: it depends. Here’s how to decide.

When DIY makes sense

  • You’re a small team or a start-up with a tight budget.

  • You know your business well and can be honest with each other.

  • You need a clear direction quickly, not a polished rebrand.

  • Someone on the team is happy to facilitate.

When an agency makes sense

  • You need an outside view because the team is too close to it or divided.

  • You need identity, guidelines and rollout as well as the thinking.

  • Nobody has the time to run and follow up properly.

  • The stakes are high, such as a merger or a big repositioning.

The middle route

You can do the strategy yourselves, then bring in a designer for the identity. A clear strategy makes any designer faster and cheaper, because they aren’t guessing. Many agencies also run their own workshops with a template like this.

How to choose

Ask three questions. What’s our budget? How much time do we really have? Do we need an outside voice? Two yeses to DIY, and you’re probably fine.

If DIY sounds right, BrandBench for FigJam gives you the structure, and 5 rules for facilitators will help you run it well.