Advice
By Simon Fairhurst
Can AI build your brand? Where it helps and where a workshop wins
You can ask an AI for a brand strategy in 30 seconds. Mission, values, tone of voice, even a list of dos and don’ts. It looks convincing, so why bother running a workshop?
Short answer: AI is great at drafting. A workshop is how you decide. The best results use both, in the right order.
What AI is good at
Used well, AI is a brilliant assistant for brand work. It’s quick, tireless and happy to try ten versions.
First drafts. Mission statements, value names, taglines and voice descriptions to react to.
Options. Ten ways to say the same thing, so you can pick the one that sounds like you.
Tidying up. Turning messy workshop notes into clean, readable copy.
Stress-testing. Asking “what would a sceptical customer say about this?”
Where AI falls short
The problems start when you use AI to decide your brand, not just to write it up.
It gives you the average. AI predicts what’s likely, which means the common answer. Ask for brand values and you’ll get “innovative, authentic, customer-focused”. Every business gets the same list, and a brand that sounds like everyone else isn’t really a brand.
It doesn’t know your business. It can’t know why you started, who you really sell to or what your best customers say. Without those details it fills the gaps with guesses. Gathering the real details is the hard part, and that’s what a workshop does.
It can’t get your team on the same page. A brand only works when the people running it agree on it. Reading a strategy isn’t the same as helping to shape it. The debate in the room, disagreements included, is where the value is.
Nobody owns the output. A list of dos and don’ts your team chose gets used. One generated for you tends to get skimmed once and forgotten.
Dos and don’ts: generic vs yours
Here’s the difference in practice. Ask AI for a brand voice with no context and you’ll get something like this:
“We are friendly, professional and passionate about helping our customers.”
Nice enough, but you could paste it onto any brand. After a workshop, with real answers from your team, you get something like this:
“We sound like a smart friend: plain English, short sentences, no buzzwords.”
“Do say ‘sign up’. Don’t say ‘onboard’.”
“Do be warm. Don’t use exclamation marks to fake it.”
That level of detail comes from your team’s choices, not from a prompt. It’s also something a new hire can follow on day one.
How to use both
Don’t pick one. Use each for what it does best.
Run the workshop first. Get your team’s real answers on audience, difference and voice. The BrandBench FigJam template guides you through it step by step.
Use AI to draft. Give it your workshop outputs and ask for wording options. Now it has something real to work with.
Edit and agree as a team. Cut what doesn’t sound like you. This is where the brand becomes yours.
Ask AI to challenge it. Try “where is this vague?” and “what would a competitor copy?” Treat it as a sharp critic, not the decision-maker.
Where BrandBench fits
BrandBench gives you the structure AI can’t: a guided workshop that pulls the right answers out of your team. The Pro version has 16 exercises across strategy, positioning, persona and narrative, including voice and tone sliders and a do and don’t list. There’s also a free version on Figma Community if you want to try it first.
The short version
AI is a great drafter and a weak decision-maker.
Real inputs beat clever prompts.
A brand your team built together is a brand your team will use.
New to this? Start with what brand strategy is, then use this brand workshop agenda to plan your session.