Advice
By Simon Fairhurst
A logo is not a brand: where look and feel falls short
I’m a designer, so let me say this first: look and feel matters. A well-designed logo, a considered palette and good typography make a real difference to how people see you. I wouldn’t be doing this job otherwise.
But when a brand is just a logo and a colour scheme, it tends to hit the same walls. Here’s where it falls short.
1. It looks good but says nothing
A nice logo can be completely empty. If nobody has decided what the brand stands for, the visuals have nothing to express. You get something polished that could belong to anyone.
People don’t remember how a logo is drawn. They remember what you said, how you made them feel and whether you were consistent. That all comes from the strategy.
2. Every design decision becomes a matter of taste
Without a clear brief, the choices come down to “I like it” or “I don’t”. That’s how you end up in endless rounds of feedback, with everyone suggesting a different shade of blue.
When there’s a strategy, you can ask a better question: does this fit who we are and who we’re for? That’s much easier to answer.
3. It doesn’t connect with the right people
Look and feel works best when it’s chosen for a specific audience. A playful style might suit one group and put off another. If you haven’t worked out who you’re talking to, you’re guessing. (We look at this in why understanding your audience matters.)
4. It blends in
If you haven’t looked at how your competitors present themselves, there’s a good chance you’ll end up looking like them. A clean logo and a soft palette can be lovely and still forgettable when it’s the third one a customer sees that day.
Positioning tells you where there’s room to stand out. Design then makes the most of it.
5. It’s hard to stretch
A logo is easy. Everything after is harder. How does the brand work in an email? On a sales deck? In a short social video? On a support page? Without a voice, a personality and some rules, every new format is a fresh puzzle, and the answers don’t match.
6. Your team can’t use it consistently
Colours and fonts are the easy part to share. What people need is the thinking: how we sound, what we’d never say, what good looks like. Without that, everyone fills the gaps in their own way and the brand slowly drifts.
7. You end up redoing it
This is the big one. When the brand was only ever visual, the first time the business changes direction or the message gets sharper, it all feels wrong and you start again. A brand with a strategy underneath can evolve without starting from zero.
The fix isn’t less design
The answer isn’t to care less about the visuals. It’s to give them something solid to work from. Start with the strategy: your goals, your audience, what makes you different, how you sound. Then design the look and feel to express it.
The visuals get better, the feedback gets easier and the whole brand holds together.
Want the strategy part sorted first? BrandBench walks your team through it, step by step, before you’ve opened a design tool.